This version of Charles Dickens' classic was made for the American TV network Hallmark - yes, the same people who make those syrupy greetings cards - and it's as gorgeous and dull as the picture on a box of Quality Street chocolates.
The settings and costumes are quite beautiful, rich with colour. But the adaptation is heavy-handed and crushes the life out of the story, just as the chortling, intrusive musical score kills off anything that approaches being a funny scene stone dead.
The Americans in the cast - Sally Field, who can't quite master the accent, as Betsy Trotwood and Michael Richards, who turns Micawber into a crazy variation on his manic Kramer character from Seinfeld - are joined by some reliable British types including Paul Bettany as Steerforth, Eileen Atkins as Jane Murdstone and Hugh Dancy as grown-up David. Anthony Andrews gives his usual stick-up-the-bottom performance as Edward Murdstone, who in this version is a recurring evil villain - a strange change which doesn't really work.
It came out in 2000, just a year after the superior BBC version (with Daniel Radcliffe) which you'd be far better seeking out instead.
Reviewed on: 11 Aug 2004
If you like this, try:
Review preview for David Copperfield
The quality of this production is seamless, and if there is a criticism you could say it lacks originality, remaining faithful to the novel, which, for purists, is a form of flattery.
Review preview for Nicholas Nickleby
Essentially, the film is weak on detail and strong on personality, although, even that, promises more than it delivers.
Facebook
Reddit